Kate Walsh... It just hangs on her better..

Even before I saw the pictures I knew Kate would look better because Kelly has been looking super gross lately

Kate

are you kidding me of course kate!

Kate.
Everything about Kelly s 'chunky' in this picture - the hair and the body. She's like a big rectangle in a dress.

A million times Kate. Kelly's style has been looking a little off lately.

kate, hands down

Kate has this interesting look when wearing it

It looks great on Kate

Looks like I am one of the few who voted Kelly.

Kate, no doubt.

I LOVE Kelly but Kate just looks absolutely stunning.

Kate looks Amazing! She looks way better than Kelly. I Love Kate! She is gorgeous!

I dunno, I don't think the dress really suits Kate. It looks like she's wearing a bridal veil around her neck. Not a dress. Somehow, it's just better suited to Kelly, IMO.

Kate!

I am just not a fan of this dress -- it's been compared to a shower curtain, and I would agree. If I had to choose I'd say the color looks better on Kelly.

this is a dress where thinner is better

This is the type of dress where it's pretty in theory but doesn't really look good on anyone. I'm not blown away by either one of them but Kate wears it better.

definitely kate, though im not a fan of either in particular.

lol. kelly looks really pudgy. cute but it's not flattering. i vote kate.

Kate.

Kate no doubt because I think this dress looks better on thinner person...... but Kate is amazing and stunning

i love kate she is so adorable in almost anything she wears!

Neither... stop wearing expensive curtains.

Kate, it suits her more.

Kate Walsh, hands down.

Kelly's hair looks way severe. I voted Kate.

Kelly looks like crap in that.

Kate

I'm actually just not a big fan of this dress period, so I am going to say neither of them.

Kelly NEEDS to work on her figure. The dress sucks. You need to be a stick to pull it off. Sorry, Kell. You just aren't anything close to a stick.

I love Kelly, but they style suits Kate's figure.

kate look so much better in it.
i don't know what it is but the dress just doesn't look quite right on kelly. i love her and all but the dress just isn't for her.

i would just like to say that the dress is really ugly

it makes kelly look like a big green blob monster...

Kelly isn't muscular enough to pull of this look. Also her hair mimics the dress and it just looks wrong!
Kate looks better.

Even though the dress isn't great I think Kate wore it better.

Yuck ... horrible dress. =P Kelly looks pudgy in it and Kate like she's wearing a green sack.

OMG, it looks ugly on both of them. ;P

Kate no doubt.

of course kate walsh ?
she is winner.

Kate of course

Kelly is a bit too heavy to show herself off in that dress, I love her music but she needs to tone up!

kate

THis dress is GREAT!

...GET OUTTA BED, THERE'LL BE NO MORE NAPPING!

It just does not compliment Kelly at all unfortunately. I like the girl, but this look is not good.

kate rules!!!! kelly should get on a diet!!!