this girl is beautifull..no matter what happens..and shes talented too...but i think she has an eating disorder.. i feell reallly sorri for her.

It is pretty obvious that she has an eating disorder. She is so gorgeous and I hope she can get back to her previous weight. Lately she seems to have gained a few pounds back yet she is still too thin.

I'm split. As are the votes currently. But deep down inside I know that the pic on the left is beautiful, and the one on the right is tragic.

She looks better healthy

I haven't thought she looked healthy in a long time. She looked so much better before she was just bones.

shes still pretty but way too skinny

Maybe she has justed toned up at the gym.

She looks great anyway.

You can only get smarter, by playing a smarter opponent..

she lost all that weight a long time ago.....
anyway, she seems to get more popular after her weight loss

she's gorgeous no matter what but I think she's got an eating dissorder

That girl looks troubled! That is NOT the look of a healthy young lady!

I think it's so sad that many of these starlets are practically forced to become size 0's or size 2's so they won't be called fat by the media! Kate was gorgeous before and now she looks like a skeleton with a wig!Sadly all of these girls who develop eating disorders right in front of our eyes become more the popular/famous for it! Think about Nicole Ritchie she went from just some rich kid on the Simple Life to an all of a sudden style maven and It girl after losing a drastic amount of weight and buying better clothes to hang on her 90 pound body!

She definitely looks as if she has a eating disorder. She looks better with weight on her. Being so skinny makes her look much older. Sad because she wasn't no where near pudgy, fat, obese etc. Sad what peer pressure does.

yikes she used to be pretty i mean she's still pretty but she used to look better