i think all the contestants on the show now and in previous seasons prove that it's neither racist or 'weightist'.... otherwise how could Rubin have won>????

I think that statement is completely ridiculous! (talking in Simon's accent

OR Fantasia.....

Hahahaha I don't think it is, but I do think Antonella needs to go home! I love that Simon told her she was done, lmao!

We all voted that Rosie needs to shut up! Lol. Hey Liza- please put a "what girls need to go home" poll up! Thx!

antonella DOES need to go home! she sucks... as you and i were discussing before t_hive, it's obviously the boys voting for her! hahaha

ok... will do! haha

Antonella DOES need to go home, and it's not because of her recent 'media attention." She vocally sucks.

yeah, she can't sing

or at least not compared to the other girls~

wow Rosie is an idiot!! she really does need to shut up!

Yeah Rosie is just dumb.

antonella sucks at singing.

ok. TECHNICALLY. antonella didn't like officially take nudie pix of herself to be on the internet. frenchie did. so.

ITA, misstiffie. But Antonella still can't sing and needs to get the boot. Darn you, lustful teenaged boy population!!

Rosie needs to just shut up. So annoying and self-righteous and opinionated.

neither imo.

_________________________________________________

* yeah mon! *

Rosie is just full of hot air, as always. They need to treat her depression other than with the medicine they gave her,it isn't an antidepressant she needs, its an anti --- hole pill.

Offtopic: I just LOVE that green dress

Antonella should have been kicked off a long time ago just for wearing that hideous dress.....

Jacki
_______________________________________________________________
Brooke Shields, during an interview to become spokesperson for a federal anti-smoking campaign
Smoking kills. If you're killed, you've lost a very important part of your life.

I'm so behind on American Idol. But, I think this whole "controversy" is stupid. Frenchie was kicked off for posing for paid porn. Antonella had stupid racy pictures that she and her friends took together. That seems really different to me...?