Okay, so I am SO FREAKIN' TIRED of hearing about Brad Pitt on the gossip sites (no offense to PopSugar. Or Ima, haha). And I think he's a good looking guy but he's never been on my short list of potential movie-star boyfriends.
But I have to admit, the guy's a decent actor. I have never had any interest in seeing the movies where he plays a romantic or heroic lead: A River Runs Through It, Legends of the Fall, Seven Years in Tibet, Meet Joe Black, Troy... they sound like total snoozers to me.
But Pitt can play the hell out of a dark and/or quirky role. Some of my favorites:
Brad as the stoner roommate Floyd in True Romance. Hilarious.
Pitt as creepy redneck serial murderer Early in Kalifornia
Detective Mills in Se7en. Warning: SPOILER ALERT! This is the end of the movie so don't watch if you ever plan on seeing it.
Crazy Jeffrey in Twelve Monkeys.
Mickey in Snatch
And my absolute favorite, Tyler Durden in Fight Club.
Troy, though, was lame. I mean if you're going to do history, at least do what really happened. 
I did love Legends of the Fall and A River Runs Through It.
Tyler Durden is my all-time favorite also. He makes crazy delicious!